| 1 | Bishop Vesey's Grammar School | 94.4 compositeOfsted33.3 Att828.6 EM5+32.5 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Sutton Coldfield, West Midlands | Outstanding 2024-04-30 |
| 2 | Wolverhampton Girls' High School | 93.7 compositeOfsted33.3 Att827.9 EM5+32.4 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Wolverhampton, West Midlands | Outstanding 2023-11-28 |
| 3 | King Edward VI Camp Hill School for Boys | 93.6 compositeOfsted33.3 Att828.0 EM5+32.2 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Birmingham, West Midlands | Outstanding 2023-11-22 |
| 4 | King Edward VI School | 92.5 compositeOfsted28.3 Att830.9 EM5+33.3 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Stratford-upon-Avon, West Midlands | Outstanding 2021-11-30×0.85 |
| 5 | Stratford Girls' Grammar School | 91.5 compositeOfsted28.3 Att829.9 EM5+33.3 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Stratford-upon-Avon, West Midlands | Outstanding 2022-09-27×0.85 |
| 6 | King Edward VI Camp Hill School for Girls | 90.8 compositeOfsted28.3 Att829.8 EM5+32.7 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Birmingham, West Midlands | Outstanding 2021-11-17×0.85 |
| 7 | Alcester Grammar School | 89.0 compositeOfsted28.3 Att827.3 EM5+33.3 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Alcester, West Midlands | Outstanding 2022-12-07×0.85 |
| 8 | Newport Girls' High School Academy | 88.4 compositeOfsted28.3 Att827.9 EM5+32.2 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Newport, West Midlands | Outstanding 2022-11-01×0.85 |
| 9 | Queen Mary's Grammar School | 88.2 compositeOfsted28.3 Att827.5 EM5+32.4 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Walsall, West Midlands | Outstanding 2023-03-28×0.85 |
| 10 | Lawrence Sheriff School | 88.2 compositeOfsted28.3 Att827.8 EM5+32.0 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Rugby, West Midlands | Outstanding 2022-03-29×0.85 |
| 11 | Queen Mary's High School | 87.3 compositeOfsted28.3 Att827.2 EM5+31.7 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Walsall, West Midlands | Outstanding 2021-10-12×0.85 |
| 12 | King Edward VI Aston School | 87.1 compositeOfsted28.3 Att826.4 EM5+32.4 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Birmingham, West Midlands | Outstanding 2022-05-10×0.85 |
| 13 | King Edward VI Five Ways School | 85.3 compositeOfsted25.0 Att828.1 EM5+32.2 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Birmingham, West Midlands | Good 2023-11-28 |
| 14 | King Edward VI Handsworth Grammar School for Boys | 83.9 compositeOfsted25.0 Att826.7 EM5+32.2 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Birmingham, West Midlands | Good 2024-04-16 |
| 15 | Sutton Coldfield Grammar School for Girls | 83.8 compositeOfsted21.2 Att829.4 EM5+33.1 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Sutton Coldfield, West Midlands | Good 2022-11-08×0.85 |
| 16 | Rugby High School | 82.1 compositeOfsted21.2 Att827.7 EM5+33.1 | Grammar · Day · 6th | Rugby, West Midlands | Good 2022-11-15×0.85 |
| 17 | Eden Girls' Leadership Academy, Birmingham | 80.8 compositeOfsted33.3 Att823.0 EM5+24.4 | Free School · Day | Birmingham, West Midlands | Outstanding 2024-02-06 |
| 18 | Haberdashers' Adams | 79.4 compositeOfsted21.2 Att826.6 EM5+31.5 | Grammar · Boarding · 6th | Newport, West Midlands | Good 2022-05-10×0.85 |
| 19 | Kenilworth School and Sixth Form | 76.5 compositeOfsted33.3 Att821.3 EM5+21.9 | Academy · Day · 6th | Kenilworth, West Midlands | Outstanding 2023-11-07 |
| 20 | Eden Boys' Leadership Academy, Birmingham East | 75.8 compositeOfsted28.3 Att822.5 EM5+24.9 | Free School · Day | Birmingham, West Midlands | Outstanding 2023-01-18×0.85 |
| 21 | King Edward VI Handsworth School | 70.5 composite | Grammar · Day · 6th | Birmingham, West Midlands | — 2024-12-17 |
| 22 | Fairfield High School | 69.0 compositeOfsted33.3 Att818.6 EM5+17.1 | Academy · Day | Hereford, West Midlands | Outstanding 2023-11-28 |
| 23 | Arden | 67.8 compositeOfsted21.2 Att822.1 EM5+24.4 | Academy · Day · 6th | Solihull, West Midlands | Good 2022-06-14×0.85 |
| 24 | Haybridge High School and Sixth Form | 66.8 compositeOfsted21.2 Att822.0 EM5+23.6 | Academy · Day · 6th | Stourbridge, West Midlands | Good 2022-09-28×0.85 |
| 25 | Endon High School | 66.3 compositeOfsted25.0 Att820.1 EM5+21.3 | Academy · Day | Stoke-on-Trent, West Midlands | Good 2023-10-04 |