| 1 | The King's School Period 202122 | 48.4 | Academy · Day | Pontefract, Yorkshire and the Humber | Good |
| 2 | Titus Salt School Period 202425 | 47.2 | State · Day · 6th | Bradford, Yorkshire and the Humber | Good |
| 3 | Archbishop Holgate's School, A Church of England Academy Period 202122 | 46.3 | Academy · Day · 6th | York, Yorkshire and the Humber | Outstanding |
| 4 | Ripon Grammar School Period 202122 | 46.2 | Grammar · Boarding · 6th | Ripon, Yorkshire and the Humber | Good |
| 5 | Wolfreton School and Sixth Form College Period 202223 | 46.1 | Academy · Day · 6th | Hull, Yorkshire and the Humber | — |
| 6 | Silverdale School Period 202122 | 45.3 | Academy · Day · 6th | Sheffield, Yorkshire and the Humber | Good |
| 7 | Ron Dearing UTC Period 202122 | 45.0 | Free School · Day · 6th | Hull, Yorkshire and the Humber | Outstanding |
| 8 | Meadowhead School Academy Trust Period 202122 | 44.9 | Academy · Day · 6th | Sheffield, Yorkshire and the Humber | Good |
| 9 | Penistone Grammar School Period 202122 | 44.7 | State · Day · 6th | Sheffield, Yorkshire and the Humber | — |
| 10 | St Mary's College, Voluntary Catholic Academy Period 202122 | 44.5 | Academy · Day · 6th | Hull, Yorkshire and the Humber | Outstanding |
| 11 | Brinsworth Academy Period 202122 | 44.1 | Academy · Day · 6th | Rotherham, Yorkshire and the Humber | — |
| 12 | Woldgate School and Sixth Form College Period 202122 | 44.0 | Academy · Day · 6th | York, Yorkshire and the Humber | — |
| 13 | Wath Academy Period 202223 | 44.0 | Academy · Day · 6th | Rotherham, Yorkshire and the Humber | Good |
| 14 | Wickersley School and Sports College Period 202122 | 43.7 | Academy · Day · 6th | Rotherham, Yorkshire and the Humber | Good |
| 15 | All Saints Catholic School York Period 202122 | 43.7 | Academy · Day · 6th | York, Yorkshire and the Humber | Outstanding |
| 16 | Ilkley Grammar School Period 202122 | 43.7 | Academy · Day · 6th | Ilkley, Yorkshire and the Humber | — |
| 17 | Guiseley School Period 202425 | 43.5 | State · Day · 6th | Leeds, Yorkshire and the Humber | Good |
| 18 | Fulford School Period 202425 | 43.3 | Academy · Day · 6th | York, Yorkshire and the Humber | Outstanding |
| 19 | Horsforth School Period 202122 | 43.2 | Academy · Day · 6th | Leeds, Yorkshire and the Humber | — |
| 20 | King Ecgbert School Period 202122 | 43.0 | Academy · Day · 6th | Sheffield, Yorkshire and the Humber | — |
| 21 | Allerton High School Period 202324 | 42.8 | State · Day · 6th | Leeds, Yorkshire and the Humber | — |
| 22 | Ryburn Valley High School Period 202122 | 42.5 | Academy · Day · 6th | Sowerby Bridge, Yorkshire and the Humber | — |
| 23 | Minsthorpe Community College Period 202223 | 42.4 | Academy · Day · 6th | Pontefract, Yorkshire and the Humber | — |
| 24 | Beacon Academy Period 202425 | 42.3 | Academy · Day | Cleethorpes, Yorkshire and the Humber | — |
| 25 | Mercia School Period 202425 | 42.1 | Free School · Day · 6th | Sheffield, Yorkshire and the Humber | Outstanding |