| 1 | Shrewsbury High School GDST Period 202425 | 5.70 | Independent · Day · 6th | Unknown, West Midlands | — |
| 2 | Green Oak Academy Period 202425 | 5.68 | Independent · Day | Birmingham, West Midlands | Good |
| 3 | Stafford Grammar School Period 202425 | 5.51 | Independent · Day · 6th | Unknown, West Midlands | — |
| 4 | Priory School Period 202425 | 5.33 | Independent · Day · 6th | Unknown, West Midlands | — |
| 5 | St. Dominic's Grammar School Period 202425 | 5.33 | Independent · Day · 6th | Stafford, West Midlands | — |
| 6 | RGS Dodderhill Period 202425 | 4.93 | Independent · Day | Unknown, West Midlands | — |
| 7 | Royal Grammar School Worcester Period 202425 | 4.93 | Independent · Day · 6th | Worcester, West Midlands | — |
| 8 | Tettenhall College Incorporated Period 202425 | 4.83 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Wolverhampton, West Midlands | — |
| 9 | Hydesville Tower School Period 202425 | 4.81 | Independent · Day | Unknown, West Midlands | — |
| 10 | Lichfield Cathedral School Period 202425 | 4.54 | Independent · Day · 6th | Lichfield, West Midlands | — |
| 11 | Denstone College Period 202425 | 4.47 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Uttoxeter, West Midlands | — |
| 12 | Excellence Girls Academy Period 202425 | 4.47 | Independent · Day | Stoke-on-Trent, West Midlands | Good |
| 13 | Oswestry School Period 202425 | 4.27 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Oswestry, West Midlands | — |
| 14 | Hazrat Khadijatul Kubra Girls School Period 202425 | 4.26 | Independent · Day | Birmingham, West Midlands | — |
| 15 | Moreton Hall School Period 202425 | 4.12 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Oswestry, West Midlands | — |
| 16 | Highclare School Period 202425 | 4.03 | Independent · Day · 6th | West Midlands, West Midlands | — |
| 17 | Newcastle-under-Lyme School Period 202425 | 3.95 | Independent · Day · 6th | Newcastle-under-Lyme, West Midlands | — |
| 18 | Arnold Lodge School Period 202425 | 3.80 | Independent · Day · 6th | Leamington Spa, West Midlands | — |
| 19 | Emmanuel School Period 202425 | 3.78 | Independent · Day · 6th | Walsall, West Midlands | — |
| 20 | Bowbrook House School Period 202425 | 3.77 | Independent · Day | Worcestershire, West Midlands | — |
| 21 | Madinatul Uloom Al Islamiya School Period 202425 | 3.57 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Worcestershire, West Midlands | Requires Improvement |
| 22 | Pattison College Period 202425 | 3.52 | Independent · Day · 6th | Unknown, West Midlands | — |
| 23 | Hereford Cathedral School With A Junior School Period 202425 | 3.49 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Hereford, West Midlands | — |
| 24 | Adcote School for Girls Period 202425 | 3.41 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Shrewsbury, West Midlands | — |
| 25 | The British Muslim School Period 202425 | 3.37 | Independent · Boarding | West Midlands, West Midlands | Requires Improvement |