| 26 | Newcastle-under-Lyme School | 38.3 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%7.0 VA9.6 Att88.1 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Day · 6th | Newcastle-under-Lyme, West Midlands | — |
| 27 | Ellesmere College | 37.5 composite | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Ellesmere, West Midlands | — |
| 28 | Birchfield School | 37.5 composite | Independent · Day | Wolverhampton, West Midlands | — |
| 29 | Emmanuel School | 37.5 composite | Independent · Day · 6th | Walsall, West Midlands | — |
| 30 | Malvern St James | 37.3 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%4.8 VA10.1 Att88.9 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Malvern, West Midlands | — |
| 31 | Edgbaston High School for Girls | 36.3 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%4.2 VA10.4 Att87.9 EM5+0.2 | Independent · Day · 6th | Birmingham, West Midlands | — |
| 32 | Shrewsbury School | 35.9 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%6.1 VA11.6 Att84.7 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Shrewsbury, West Midlands | — |
| 33 | St George's School Edgbaston | 35.6 compositeAAB%2.6 VA15.4 Att89.5 EM5+8.2 | Independent · Day · 6th | West Midlands, West Midlands | — |
| 34 | Royal Grammar School Worcester | 35.5 compositeAAB%9.5 VA13.6 Att812.4 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Day · 6th | Worcester, West Midlands | — |
| 35 | Mander Portman Woodward Independent College | 34.5 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%2.9 VA11.6 Att86.6 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Day · 6th | Birmingham, West Midlands | — |
| 36 | Wolverhampton Grammar School | 34.2 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%6.2 VA9.0 Att85.5 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Day · 6th | Wolverhampton, West Midlands | — |
| 37 | Princethorpe College | 33.8 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%3.1 VA10.6 Att86.6 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Day · 6th | Rugby, West Midlands | — |
| 38 | St Dominic's Priory School | 33.2 composite | Independent · Day | Stone, West Midlands | — |
| 39 | Bredon School | 32.6 compositeOfsted15.6 VA12.9 Att84.1 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Tewkesbury, West Midlands | — |
| 40 | Rugby School | 32.1 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%6.6 VA9.8 Att82.2 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Rugby, West Midlands | — |
| 41 | Lucton School | 31.8 compositeOfsted15.6 VA11.8 Att84.4 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Leominster, West Midlands | — |
| 42 | Bowbrook House School | 31.8 compositeOfsted18.5 Att811.8 EM5+1.5 | Independent · Day | Worcestershire, West Midlands | — |
| 43 | Abbey College in Malvern | 31.0 compositeOfsted15.6 VA13.6 Att81.8 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Malvern, West Midlands | — |
| 44 | The British Muslim School | 30.3 composite | Independent · Boarding | West Midlands, West Midlands | Requires Improvement |
| 45 | Madinatul Uloom Al Islamiya School | 28.8 composite | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Worcestershire, West Midlands | Requires Improvement |
| 46 | Hazrat Khadijatul Kubra Girls School | 28.7 composite | Independent · Day | Birmingham, West Midlands | — |
| 47 | Redstone Academy for Girls | 28.1 composite | Independent · Day | Birmingham, West Midlands | Good |
| 48 | The Pioneers Academy | 28.1 composite | Independent · Day | Birmingham, West Midlands | Good |
| 49 | Kingswood School | 28.1 composite | Independent · Day | Solihull, West Midlands | Good |
| 50 | The Kingsley School | 28.1 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%0.0 VA10.3 Att84.2 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Day · 6th | Leamington Spa, West Midlands | — |