| 1 | Twycross House School | 58.5 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%6.5 VA9.9 Att812.9 EM5+15.7 | Independent · Day · 6th | Atherstone, East Midlands | Outstanding |
| 2 | Derby High School | 56.7 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%5.6 VA9.9 Att812.0 EM5+15.7 | Independent · Day · 6th | Derby, East Midlands | — |
| 3 | Quinton House School | 54.5 compositeOfsted18.0 AAB%2.8 VA9.0 Att811.3 EM5+13.3 | Independent · Day · 6th | Unknown, East Midlands | — |
| 4 | Ratcliffe College | 53.4 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%5.5 VA12.0 Att810.1 EM5+12.4 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Unknown, East Midlands | — |
| 5 | Al-Aqsa Schools Trust | 50.4 compositeOfsted13.9 Att816.8 EM5+19.7 | Independent · Day | Leicester, East Midlands | Good |
| 6 | Normanton House School | 48.2 compositeOfsted13.9 Att813.8 EM5+20.5 | Independent · Day | Derby, East Midlands | Good |
| 7 | Trent College | 42.2 compositeAAB%5.1 VA12.9 Att810.4 EM5+13.8 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Nottingham, East Midlands | — |
| 8 | Uppingham School | 37.6 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%5.3 VA14.1 Att84.7 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Unknown, East Midlands | — |
| 9 | Wellow House School | 37.5 composite | Independent · Day | Unknown, East Midlands | — |
| 10 | Leicester Grammar School Trust | 37.0 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%8.7 VA10.5 Att84.3 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Day · 6th | Leicester, East Midlands | — |
| 11 | Nottingham High School | 36.9 compositeAAB%13.6 VA11.8 Att811.5 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Day · 6th | Nottingham, East Midlands | — |
| 12 | Repton School | 36.8 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%5.3 VA10.8 Att87.2 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Derby, East Midlands | — |
| 13 | Oneschool Global Uk, Northampton Campus | 36.4 composite | Independent · Day · 6th | Northampton, East Midlands | — |
| 14 | Oakham School | 35.0 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%4.6 VA11.9 Att84.9 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Oakham, East Midlands | — |
| 15 | Oundle School | 34.9 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%6.7 VA11.5 Att83.2 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Northamptonshire, East Midlands | — |
| 16 | Lincoln Minster School | 32.9 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%4.2 VA9.9 Att84.8 EM5+0.6 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Lincoln, East Midlands | — |
| 17 | Wellingborough School | 31.1 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%3.3 VA9.0 Att85.3 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Day · 6th | Wellingborough, East Midlands | — |
| 18 | Worksop College | 30.9 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%2.4 VA9.6 Att85.4 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Worksop, East Midlands | — |
| 19 | St Crispin's School | 30.3 compositeAAB%2.5 VA12.3 Att88.5 EM5+6.9 | Independent · Day | Leicester, East Midlands | — |
| 20 | Bosworth Independent School | 29.6 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%2.9 VA11.3 Att81.7 EM5+0.2 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Unknown, East Midlands | — |
| 21 | Abbotsholme School | 29.4 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%0.0 VA9.4 Att86.5 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Uttoxeter, East Midlands | — |
| 22 | Dixie Grammar School | 28.4 compositeOfsted13.5 AAB%0.8 VA10.1 Att84.0 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Day · 6th | Nuneaton, East Midlands | — |
| 23 | Stamford Endowed Schools | 26.9 compositeAAB%4.2 VA13.6 Att89.1 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Boarding · 6th | Lincolnshire, East Midlands | — |
| 24 | Kirkstone House School | 26.9 composite | Independent · Day | Peterborough, East Midlands | — |
| 25 | Pitsford School | 25.6 compositeOfsted4.5 AAB%3.9 VA10.2 Att87.0 EM5+0.0 | Independent · Day · 6th | Northampton, East Midlands | — |