| 1 | Spratton Hall School | 374 pupils | Independent · Day | Unknown, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 2 | St Hugh's School | 174 pupils | Independent · Boarding | Woodhall Spa, East Midlands | — |
| 3 | Winchester House School | 338 pupils | Independent · Boarding | Unknown, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 4 | Repton Preparatory School | 399 pupils | Independent · Boarding | Derby, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 5 | Witham Hall School | 217 pupils | Independent · Boarding | Bourne, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 6 | Stamford Junior School | 330 pupils | Independent · Boarding | Stamford, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 7 | Land of Learning Primary School | Outstanding | Independent · Day | Leicester, East Midlands | Outstanding |
| 8 | Fairfield Prep School | 444 pupils | Independent · Day | Unknown, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 9 | Copthill Independent Day School & Nursery | 299 pupils | Independent · Day | Stamford, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 10 | Laxton Junior School | 256 pupils | Independent · Day | Unknown, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 11 | Akeley Wood Junior School | 222 pupils | Independent · Day | Northamptonshire, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 12 | Brooke Priory School | 144 pupils | Independent · Day | Oakham, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 13 | Ayscoughfee Hall School | 120 pupils | Independent · Day | Spalding, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 14 | Plumtree School | 110 pupils | Independent · Day | Nottingham, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 15 | Highfields School | 107 pupils | Independent · Day | Newark, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 16 | St Peter and St Paul School | 104 pupils | Independent · Day | Chesterfield, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 17 | Burton Hathow Preparatory School | 103 pupils | Independent · Day | Lincoln, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 18 | Leicester Preparatory School | 61 pupils | Independent · Day | Leicester, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 19 | Leicester Islamic Academy | Good | Independent · Day | Leicester, East Midlands | Good |
| 20 | Salterford House School | 77 pupils | Independent · Day | Nottingham, East Midlands | — ISI · Good |
| 21 | Fig Tree Primary School | Good | Independent · Day | Nottingham, East Midlands | Good |
| 22 | Greenwich House School | Good | Independent · Day | Louth, East Midlands | Good |
| 23 | Twycross House Pre-Preparatory School | Good | Independent · Day | Atherstone, East Midlands | Good |
| 24 | Green Crescent School | Requires Improvement | Independent · Day | Nottingham, East Midlands | Requires Improvement |
| 25 | St Anselm's School | 123 pupils | Independent · Boarding | Bakewell, East Midlands | — |